PHAMIT Site Profiles

 
   
Center for AIDS Rights (CAR)
 
   

Center for AIDS Rights (CAR) is the implementing organization in Thailand for the cross-border PROMDAN project in partnership with PATH and CWPD in Cambodia. CAR is at the forefront of advocacy on relevant HIV issues such as fighting against patents that limit availability of ARV, and is an outspoken representative for migrants’ rights.

 
As of December, 2006
 
Chonburi
 
 
 

Although Chonburi is mainly known for its tourist area of Pattaya, it also ranks as a province with one of the highest numbers of migrant workers. The province has a sizable fishing and agriculture industry, and has had a construction boom. In 2004, a total of 50,017 migrants registered with a 38/1 ID (By nationality: 38% from Burma with a 1.9:1 ratio of men to women, 45% from Cambodia with a 2.5:1 ratio of men to women, and 17% from Laos with an almost 1:1 ratio of men to women); of those, 33,654 migrants obtained work permits. As of 2005, the number had diminished to 25,973 receiving work permits, and it has continued to dwindle since, with the numbers becoming confused with the changes in registration policies.  As of 2005, the composition of registered migrants had changed to 45% from Burma, 32% from Cambodia and 23% from Laos. 

 
Chong Sanae San Village is a village on the eastern coast of Chonburi Province. There are 5,000 local Thais and another 1,000 Thais who have migrated for work here; but they are seemingly outnumbered by the 7,000-10,000 migrants in the area, of which, almost eighty percent are male. Of the migrants present, around seventy percent are from Burma, constituted by Mon, Burmese and Karen groups, with Cambodians, mostly from Kompong Cham Province, making up the other thirty percent.
 
 
     
 
Target Groups

Some of the migrants in this area have been here ten years, and many are still sending money home. There are also those who have married with Thais, and those who have worked for the some employer for six years or more.

The turns of the economy have affected local businesses, with the fishing industry being hardest hit by the rising price of gas. Because boats are going out less or for shorter periods and making less money, some migrants have moved into agriculture and construction. Migrants are regularly coming to this area for work, irregardless of the season. As a result, it is estimated that 60 to 70 percent of migrants present are unregistered.

This area is special in the sense that it is under the protection of the navy, which means that police are not allowed to arrest fishermen on boats or in the dock area; irregardless, the police do carry out arrests on a weekly basis in migrant communities, which are not under this special protection. Some migrants in the community have an ID, but don’t have health insurance, which is unusual, as both are supposedly co-required. Also, it is reported that migrants are able to register all year round here.

 

Although there are families that make up communities, there are not many Cambodian women present, which is significant, considering the number of Cambodian men in the area, most of whom work on fishing boats. In relation to this, there are three direct sex venues in the area with about twenty women in total, both Thai and Cambodian ages 15-28. Two of the venues have only Cambodian women. These women come from Battambang Province in Cambodia. Many of them go to Pattaya first, then come to this area and then rotate back to Battambang. Some may even rotate through this circuit more than once.

In Chong Sanae San Village, there are around sixty karaoke bars, of which only around twenty or so are open at any one time depending on the season. Most of the women working in these shops are from Essarn (Northeast Thailand), and many of the girls are only in their mid to late teens. Mainly fishermen frequent these places as they have no where else to go during their free time on land. These shops do not sell sex, even though the customers may become “boyfriends” who the young women may have sex with. In these cases, it is unlikely that they will use a condom. The women may have more than one boyfriend, a situation that not only increases vulnerability to HIV, but results in the men having violent fights over the women.

Migrant fishermen mostly stay on the boats if they are single, or else they stay in the dock area owned by their employer. If they are married, their families stay in the pier area and work sorting fish. Boats go out at either 9 p.m. or 1 p.m. and return around sunrise. Most boats go out and return daily, but there are those that go out either for three days or weeks at a time.

Cambodian families that are here have congregated into nine communities; there are also around twelve communities of Mon and Burmese groups that live separately. In all, these communities are spread out over seven fish drying factories and eleven piers throughout the area. Communities are generally very sanitary and clean.

Migrants living in the community mostly live in family units in a single room that costs around 1,000 Baht plus 700 Baht for utilities each month. Many other families live in shacks or dorms on or near fish drying factories where they work. These factories are simply small fields where they spread out fish on drying nets, and then collect them once they are desiccated.
 
In the migrant community there are some children present. Even though many of them are fluent in Thai, the problem with entering Thai schools is that their parents are highly mobile, and many are not registered. Ages of children present range from four to thirteen, but most children age ten go back home to “go to school,” but it is uncertain if they really are attending school or if they are starting to work. It is known that if they remain here they will help their parents at work by snapping the heads off of dried fish.
 

Currently, three Cambodian and one Mon child are attending Thai schools in this area. Many of the children that grow up here speak Thai, making language less of a barrier. The problem is that the parents are often mobile, and since they don’t have Thai language skills or else have low education, it is difficult to assist their children with homework

In the migrant community, a person with symptomatic HIV is occasionally found. In the past there were a considerable number of migrants known or suspected to have HIV, but most of them have passed away. Those migrants that found out they had HIV while working in this area were unwilling to return home and died here. One Karen person recently died from AIDS. Currently, there are four individuals present in the community that are confirmed to have HIV, all of Mon ethnicity. One of the migrants with HIV is using his own funds to purchase ARV from a private hospital; otherwise, migrants have no public access to the life-saving medicines. Many migrant women find out their HIV status when they are pregnant and go to the ante-natal clinic. Yet, until just recently, the hospital did not have VCT available in migrants’ language.

 
 
Health Problems
  • Health has increased with improved access to health facilities
  • Migrants with HIV are unwilling to return home but have no access to ARV in Thailand
 
 
Activities and Strategies

CAR has two outreach teams that go out into the community and the piers. The teams are usually gender specific, with men going to the boats and women going into the community. A team usually consists of a Thai Field Officer and a migrant volunteer or Migrant Field Officer (FOM) but this varies depending on the situation and the information being disseminated.

Activities often start out by discussing migrants’ situation rather than simply launching into the specific activity - a recommendation that came from community volunteers. Once they gain the trust and establish a relationship with the community, the team is able to initiate discussion and activities about HIV the next time. The teams have a basic list of issues that they try to cover with each community and use this as a check list as a form of monitoring.

 

CAR has three levels of volunteers. The highest level of volunteers is the Migrant Field Officers (FOM). CAR has two Thai field officers and three FOM - one Mon woman and two Cambodian men. The Mon FOM acts as a translator at the hospital, and is essential in the provision of VCCT for the ANC clinic.

The next level of volunteers must be able to speak Thai and have a higher level of job security than the average migrant worker. These volunteers provide referral to health services and assist with translation, and can help organize and assist with activities as well. There are currently eleven volunteers of this level, evenly balanced between male and female for both Mon and Cambodian groups.

 

There are also community volunteers who act as a linkage between communities and CAR. There are thirty volunteers in the communities and factories, most of whom are women, and they are evenly divided between Burmese and Mon groups, and Cambodians. There are also sixty volunteers on boats and the docks - all men except for a few women in the dock areas. The volunteers in the communities and factories are more stable than the fishermen. Even though volunteers on boats drop-out regularly because fishermen are highly mobile, CAR is able to maintain the number of volunteers through regular recruitment and training.

Newly recruited migrant volunteers go through a series of trainings, with a training held every three months. If a volunteer goes through the series of three trainings, they get an official bag. At each training volunteers are given condoms and IEC materials to distribute, so that they contribute in some way, regardless if they complete the course of trainings. Volunteers who do not complete three trainings can still act as volunteers. These people act as “eyes and the ears” to inform CAR of the situation on the ground; they help recruit participants for activities, and they distribute condoms and IEC.

 
 

Cambodians are generally more receptive to condom distribution than other groups. Cambodian women, especially compared to Mon women, are very forward in requesting condoms. This is because Cambodians have had previous exposure to condoms in their home country and feel more comfortable about requesting or discussing condoms, whereas Mon groups are still traditional and shy about openly discussing sex or condoms.

 

CAR has twenty-five distribution boxes placed throughout the target community that FOs refill. One box is supplied with 50 pieces once a week, depending on how many pieces are remaining. Boxes are located in snooker halls, on piers, at stores, in fish drying factories, in the communities and at the drop-in center. Volunteers oversee the boxes, help promote condoms to community members and notify CAR when they need to be refilled.

 

There aren’t any sex worker volunteers, but the group has trainings once every three months. The women working as direct sex workers come and receive the condoms in person each week, and have a brief activity. Each woman receives fifty pieces, and may come back for more before the week is up. Unfortunately, the women have complained that PHAMIT condoms don’t smell good (even the scented ones).

Although karaoke bars do not provide condoms, they also do not sell sex. Even though it has been suggested to provide condoms, the owners’ fear is that having condoms would insinuate it is a direct sex venue resulting in closure by the police. The ability to access karaoke shops with activities, however, has been increased through a linkage with an informal association of owners.

 

Family planning activities are a major part of outreach to communities. In the communities where women are the main target group, activities teach about female anatomy using a model and aprons that show the reproductive system. CAR teams and volunteers also assist in referring pregnant women to ANC clinics and assist with translation at the hospital. Pregnant women are first brought to the drop-in center to receive a full explanation of what they should expect before they are taken to the hospital by the CAR team.

Prevalence of STI is mostly among Cambodian fishermen, sex workers and some karaoke women. They can go to the community hospital for treatment and CAR assists when necessary. If they are unregistered, treatment costs around 200 Baht.

 

There is no PLHA support group in this area, so migrant PLHA join the PLHA support group in Rayong, about one hour away. Currently there are two women, one Cambodian and one Mon, and one Mon man attending the group from Chonburi. The Mon man purchases ARV on his own for 1,000 Baht a month.

Many other PLHA in the community are not open about their HIV status. CAR field officers give advice about health on an individual basis to these individual without necessarily mentioning HIV. The strategy is to inform the community and individuals who may have HIV about HIV and its effects in order to reduce stigma. With greater understanding, it is anticipated that people will be more willing to receive notification of their HIV status, and this will in turn affect their willingness to be open about their status. However, it is unclear the level of stigma in the communities.
 

There are thirty kids in CAR’s day care program ranging in ages from four to twelve years. The class runs half a day until around 11 a.m. The children learn Thai and either Mon or Burmese language or both (depending on their ethnicity).

CAR has workshops with teachers and education officials to try and encourage greater enrollment of migrant children. One thing that CAR has been requesting is the lifting of the requirement for identification documents to enter school.

 
The main rights issue CAR works on is health, but they also touch on other basic rights such as labor rights, rights accompanying registration, and birth registration rights. Their main rights activities are to communicate directly with the target groups to inform them of their rights so that they are aware and can make their own decisions.
 
 

With minimum wage issues for example, CAR discusses options of redress, such as how to change employers using the official system. They also explain how to use the health insurance card, such as where they can go to receive the subsidized rate, what conditions are covered, how much services should cost, etc. When there are problems with migrants receiving services at the hospital, CAR will talk directly with the head of the hospital to try and resolve the issue.

Overall, the situation of migrants in this area has improved because the government has given importance to the migrant issue. This is in large part an outcome of the Provincial Migrant Committee that CAR organized as part of the PHAMIT Project.

The committee meets monthly. CAR participates as a member of the committee along with representatives from three health centers, the Provincial Health Office, the Community Hospital, the local Sub-district office, village headmen, police, immigration and the fishery association. CAR reports to the group on migrants’ situation and informs the committee of their workplan.

The importance that migrant health has received by the government and the health system as a priority issue has been facilitated by the Committee, as the various health facilities are sitting members, including the local hospital. In the Committee, agreements were made on health arrangements, including the use of Migrant Health Volunteers (MHV) and mobile clinics.

CAR also regularly coordinates with employers and owners including a meeting they organize every three months. In the meeting, they talk with employers about “hot” issues, current events and health referral. This line of communication also allows CAR to talk about rights with employers in a receptive environment.

 
 
 
 

Activities

Description
 
  Outreach

Two gender-specific outreach teams go to boats or the community until they cover a list of issues that also acts as a form of monitoring. Reproductive health is a focus among women.

 
Volunteers

Different levels of volunteers are found throughout the communities and on boats. They provide referral, organize activities, distribute condoms and IEC, and act as the eyes and ears. The number of volunteers is balanced between migrants from Cambodia and Burma.

Condom distribution

There are distribution boxes at snooker halls, piers, stores, fish-drying factories, in communities and at the drop-in center. Volunteers also distribute condoms and sex workers receive condoms directly each week.

IEC materials

There has been a good response to the IEC that CAR has produced, ranging from information on HIV to labor rights in Cambodian, Lao and Burmese languages. Distributed by volunteers and at the drop-in center.

Referral and counseling

Volunteers assist with referral to the hospital and health center. There are over 250 health volunteers that have been trained by the hospital. Volunteers can provide translation, and there is a FOM that regularly provides translation including for the ANC clinic.

Community activities

Thirty kids attend CAR’s day care program, ranging from age four to twelve. Support for purchase of sanitation equipment is provided to community leaders.

Rights and advocacy Rights activities teach people how to use their health insurance cards, and inform them of their labor rights, providing information on: work hours, wages, days off, regulations for employers, and how to change employers. Formation of a Provincial Migrant Committee has positively contributed to migrants’ situation.